More dramatic change occurred for the U.S. Mint’s annual coin sets, following the proliferation of different coinage designs. The 2009 Silver Proof Set (Buy on eBay) expanded to its largest size on record, with 18 different coins. Sales officially began on July 17, 2009, with the sets priced at $52.95 each, an increase of $8 from the prior year.
Eight silver coins were included in each set with an aggregate silver content of 1.519 troy ounces. Excluding Limited Edition Silver Proof Sets and the 2018 50th Anniversary Silver Proof Set, this remains the highest silver content within a modern U.S. Mint Silver Proof Set. The increase was the result of the D.C. & U.S. Territories Quarters, which included six designs, rather than the typical five quarter designs per year. The remaining silver coins were the Kennedy Half Dollar and Roosevelt Dime.
Non-silver coins included in the set also saw an increase, driven by the 2009 Lincoln Bicentennial Cents. Four different designs were issued to mark the different stages in the life of Abraham Lincoln. The remaining coins were the four Presidential Dollars featuring William Henry Harrison, John Tyler, James K. Polk, and Zachary Taylor, the Jefferson Nickel, and the Native American Dollar. The final coin was the first issue of a new series featuring the Sacagawea Dollar obverse paired with annually rotating reverse designs depicting the contributions and accomplishments of Native Americans.
The 2009 Silver Proof Set had final reported sales of 697,365 units. This was the lowest level in a decade, but did not generate significant excitement with collectors. As the scope of the annual set had increased, along with the issue price, total sales had been on the decline. Lower mintages failed to resonate with collectors as they had in the past. On the secondary market, the majority of the value of the set remains driven by the silver content.
Packaging for the set consisted of four separate lenses containing the coins. The first lens contained the four cents, the second lens contained the six quarters, the third lens contained the four Presidential Dollars, and the fourth lens contained the remaining coins. These were placed within a single cardboard box with “2009 United States Mint Silver Proof Set” on the front and an image of the San Francisco Mint on the back. Each set included a certificate of authenticity.
2009 Silver Proof Set Coins
- 2009-S Proof Birth and Early Childhood Lincoln Cent
- 2009-S Proof Formative Years Lincoln Cent
- 2009-S Proof Professional Life Lincoln Cent
- 2009-S Proof Presidency Lincoln Cent
- 2009-S Proof Jefferson Nickel
- 2009-S Silver Proof Roosevelt Dime
- 2009-S Silver Proof District of Columbia Quarter
- 2009-S Silver Proof Puerto Rico Quarter
- 2009-S Silver Proof Guam Quarter
- 2009-S Silver Proof American Samoa Quarter
- 2009-S Silver Proof U.S. Virgin Islands Quarter
- 2009-S Silver Proof Northern Mariana Islands Quarter
- 2009-S Silver Proof Kennedy Half Dollar
- 2009-S Proof Native American Dollar
- 2009-S Proof William Henry Harrison Presidential Dollar
- 2009-S Proof John Tyler Presidential Dollar
- 2009-S Proof James K. Polk Presidential Dollar
- 2009-S Proof Zachary Taylor Presidential Dollar
2009 Silver Proof Set Information
- Coins per Set: 18
- Face Value: $7.19
- Silver Content: 1.519 troy oz. (47.246 g)
- Original Issue Price: $52.95
- Mintage: 697,365